Is Matt Harvey to the bullpen the best solution?

Atlanta Braves v New York MetsLet’s be clear, this is not meant as a permanent move to the bullpen, but rather one simply for the remainder of 2014. Matt Harvey, the Mets ace who underwent Tommy John surgery on October 22, 2013 is trying desperately to pitch this year. He recently began throwing off of a mound, which puts his timetable of possibly pitching somewhere in the next month or two. Whether he actually pitches or not is still a matter of great debate.

On one side you have Terry Collins, Sandy Alderson, the Mets training staff and now even Harvey’s agent, Scott Boras. They are all preaching the conservative approach toward Harvey returning to the mound. ESPN quotes Boras as saying:

“The doctors are always telling us 14 to 16 months they’re having the higher success rates than they are the 10- to 12-month period,” Boras said. “So is that a definitive measure? The doctors will always tell you they’re unsure. But with elite athletes, high ‘velo’ guys, to err on conservatism and more time I think is the proper course.”

Scott Boras is, of course, protecting his client who could be looking at a monumental contract in the future if Harvey comes back healthy. If the pitcher’s competitive spirit gets the better of him though, it could be another year of recovery from injury, and another year lost from making money. And Boras likes making money.

Let’s us now assume that Harvey will pitch again in 2014. In what capacity, though? As everyone is concerned over re-injury, the most likely course would be for Harvey to start off slow, and build up his arm-strength. Rehab cannot compare to pitching in a real game, where tensions and emotions are high, and pitchers sometimes overthrow out of nervousness or passion. We saw Harvey do it during last year’s All-Star game in Flushing. If he pops back onto the mound in say, late-August, throwing 96 mph, most fans would be holding their collective breath.

Harvey is going to do what he wants on the mound, and there isn’t much anyone can do to stop him. You can’t tell a guy to throw 90 mph when he wants to throw harder. That’s why the bullpen might be the best outlet to allow Harvey to come back. By putting him in the bullpen for the remainder of 2014, it would give Collins and Alderson a more controlled atmosphere for them to oversee Harvey’s progression. That way, he can air out his arm, if just for one batter or inning at a time.

If Harvey shows no ill effects from his injury and can build off of that one batter or inning, then perhaps by the end of the season, depending on where the Mets stand in the playoff race, he might be able to start a game. This seems like the best environment to try and temper the aggressive nature of Harvey’s personality, at least for now. Next year is another story.

This all hinges on many factors. Harvey has progressed well through his long recovery process, and seems ahead of schedule. It’s hard to believe that less than one year ago, Mets fans’ hopes of being competitive sooner rather than later were delivered a huge blow. To see Harvey push himself to get back onto the mound, only to re-injury himself would crush those dreams even further, and possibly derail his entire career.

It seems like everyone but Harvey is preaching the conservative track, but eventually he is going to have to pitch. Whether that is this year or next remains to be seen. The Mets are on a hot pace right now, and the offense has really come alive of late. Does that impact us being buyer or sellers at the trade deadline? Does that mean Harvey might be coming into important games late in the season? Does that then change how Collins and Alderson handle his progression? Too many questions to answer definitely at this moment. If he comes back this year, the bullpen might be the best place to get that arm up to speed. But that is a long way off still. For now, all Mets fans can do is cheer on this suddenly smoking team, and hope that everyone acts in the best interest of continued and future success.

The Dark Knight is known for punishing his body for the sake of his goals. In this one case, let’s hope Harvey isn’t quite so much like his comic book alter-ego.

12 comments for “Is Matt Harvey to the bullpen the best solution?

  1. Tommy2cat
    July 15, 2014 at 12:39 pm

    Many games are won and lost in innings 6 thru 9. In 2006, one of our clear advantages was the bullpen, which Willie Randolph used very well. Why Omar dismantled a good portion of that bullpen has always remained a mystery, and certainly was detrimental to the team’s success in 2007-08.

    I once mused what our 2015 pitching staff could look like if Harvey anchored it as the closer. Here’s one scenario:

    Rotation – Colon, Niese, Wheeler, Gee & Syndergaard

    Righties – Harvey, Mejia, Familia, Parnell/Torres & Black
    Lefties – Edgin, Leathersich

    The above scenario is downright scary – that is a lock-down bullpen. A 2-run lead feels more like a 5-run lead. And it’s without the inclusion of any prospective free agents, which has never been Sandy’s strong suit lol.

    We also have prospective starters such as guys like Montero, Matz, Mazzoni, Fulmer, Ynao & Koch in the pipeline

    BTW – I’m not suggesting that we relegate Harvey to the bullpen, especially if Parnell were to return to form. But it’s certainly fun to think about, if not food for thought.

  2. July 15, 2014 at 1:04 pm

    Let Matt take the rest of the season off. See what happens in spring training.

  3. blastingzone
    July 15, 2014 at 1:15 pm

    Tommy2cat, I guess you don’t think much of Degrom? Except for Harvey and maybe Syndergaard he has as much if not more talent than all the other pitchers
    on your list or maybe you just forgot to include him?

    • Tommy2cat
      July 15, 2014 at 5:48 pm

      Oh Gosh! How embarrassing – I absolutely forgot deGrom. Oops! :) v

    • Tommy2cat
      July 15, 2014 at 5:48 pm

      Uh, yeah – consider Colon as traded….

      Niese, Wheeler, Gee, deGrom & Syndergaard

  4. Joe Gomes
    July 15, 2014 at 1:20 pm

    How is no. Harvey will try to throw the ball at 98 mph and possibly hurt himself again.
    Lets not lose track here. As presently composed, the Mets are not going anywhere so why take a chance with the ace of the rotation?

    Let Harvey pitch in his simulated games and if the opportunity presents itself where he can pitch an inning here or there, you let him. But letting him compete in must games, should be out of the question.

    Editor’s Note – Please do not capitalize words in your post, as that is a violation of our Comment Policy.

  5. Name
    July 15, 2014 at 1:28 pm

    Remember our genius bullpen manager Terry Collins?

    He’s the first and only reason needed (among the many many more out there) not to put Harvey in the pen.

  6. Metsense
    July 15, 2014 at 1:28 pm

    October 22, 2013 until February 15th 2015 is just shy of 16 months. Sounds about right to me.

  7. Chris F
    July 15, 2014 at 3:46 pm

    No chance. None. Zilch. Zero.

  8. July 15, 2014 at 8:53 pm

    Just something to note, Harvey recently said something about wanting to pitch in 2014 so he could go into his regular off-season routine comfortably. I’m not looking to mortgage the future for August, but if he’s still on-track come September and able to pitch some rehab, why not have him on the expanded roster? If we’re in the fabled hunt, he can aid Mejia, Familia and Black. If not, then he gets the innings he wants. And if by some miraculous stroke we’re playing in October… Happy Harvey Days can come again!

  9. blaiseda
    July 16, 2014 at 12:59 pm

    Harvey should not pitch again in 2014 even if we do get into the race. Our bullpen is already good. Let the relief pitchers who will have the roles in 2015 get their experience this year, including some September call ups from LV and/or Binghamton. Why the need to push Harvey to pitch this year? So he can be on HIS timetable? Look Harvey is a tremendous athlete and he has a drive to succeed that is world’s ahead of most, but that doesn’t make him smart and sensible. These decisions are best made in a dispassionate logical manner. I don’t associate those terms with Harvey.

  10. Sean Flattery
    July 18, 2014 at 5:21 pm

    I love Matt Harvey, but I want him no where near the mound until next season. It’s fair to consider the option, but I don’t think he’s needed now that the bullpen appears to be strong.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *