The Mets were spoiled by Yoenis Cespedes. When they acquired Cespedes at the trade deadline in 2015, he proceeded to put up a .942 OPS in 249 PA. Now the expectation is that anyone they acquire at the deadline is going to be a major contributor. But Jay Bruce didn’t help to that degree in 2016, AJ Ramos was forgettable in 2017 and now Marcus Stroman has turned into a pumpkin right before our eyes in 2019.

And to make matters worse, Anthony Kay, one of two minor leaguers dealt away for Stroman, made his major league debut Saturday night and pitched better than Stroman has done in any of his seven starts for the Mets. Kay had a Game Score of 58, while Stroman has failed to crack 50 in five of his seven games for New York and tallied scores of 54 and 51 in the other two outings.

After posting a 2.96 ERA and a 1.227 WHIP in 21 games for the Blue Jays this season, Stroman has a 5.05 ERA and a 1.738 WHIP for the Mets. He’s given neither quality nor quantity when he’s taken the mound and the question is if the Mets can afford to start him when his turn comes up next. It’s not like they have a great alternative waiting for a chance. But with a Wild Card still an outside possibility, Saturday’s putrid outing was the straw that broke this camel’s back.

The Mets need to look no further than Bruce for an example of how to handle Stroman. Back in 2016, Bruce started 16 consecutive games for the Mets from August 2 to August 19. But he put up a .547 OPS in that stretch. From that point on, it wasn’t a given that Bruce would be in the lineup and even if he did start, it wasn’t a slam dunk that he’d still be in the game when it ended. In the Mets’ final 40 games that season, Bruce made just 27 starts and he came out early in five of those.

And it worked.

In his final 92 PA, Bruce put up an .866 OPS, including 6 HR. More importantly, the Mets ended up taking the Wild Card that season. They didn’t guarantee him a start but they didn’t bury him, either. They gave him a chance to contribute and he did. And his reduced role down the stretch didn’t impact him the following season. Bruce had an .841 OPS for the Mets in 2017

The Mets need to send Stroman to the bullpen and allow him to contribute there. It’s not what they envisioned when they traded two of their top three pitching prospects to get him but there’s what’s ideal and there’s what’s necessary. Just like it’s not ideal to play infielders in the outfield but you do it when it gives you the best chance to win, the Mets need to move their big trade acquisition out of the rotation and give him Tyler Bashlor’s relief innings. Perhaps pitching in two-inning bursts, Stroman can better his 5.05 ERA for the Mets. Even if he doesn’t, it’s still an improvement over Bashlor’s 7.58 ERA in 20 games for New York this year.

And who would they put into the rotation in his place? Well, in his last three games with the Mets, Walker Lockett has a 3.86 ERA with 10 Ks in 11.2 IP. And this season in Triple-A, he had a 3.66 ERA in 59 IP.

Like so many pitchers in 2019, what’s killed Stroman in New York has been the gopher ball. With the Blue Jays this season, Stroman had a 0.7 HR/9 rate. But with the Mets, that figure has ballooned to a 1.7 mark. The worry when the trade was made was how the Mets’ poor defense would impact a guy who kept the ball in the park and pitched to contact. But since the trade, Stroman’s strikeouts have gone up and his HR rate, too. The defense hasn’t had as much opportunity to let him down. But let down we are.

For what it’s worth, Lockett has allowed just 1 HR in his last 11.2 IP for the Mets and while using the MLB ball in Triple-A this season, he gave up 5 HR in 59 IP, good for a 0.8 HR/9. Lockett was acquired to be a depth starter and with the good health enjoyed by the five starters in New York, he didn’t get a lot of opportunities. But while it’s not health-related, there should be an opportunity for him now.

The easiest thing in the world to do would be to keep Stroman starting as long as the Mets were still mathematically alive in the Wild Card race. And my expectation is that’s exactly what the Mets will do. The Mets are great at showing loyalty to guys who’ve performed well in other MLB organizations besides their own.

In the long run, few would doubt that Stroman is better than Lockett. But it’s hard not to recall the famous words of economist John Maynard Keynes. No, no, no – not “I work for a government I despise for ends I think criminal.” Rather this quote:

But this long run is a misleading guide to current affairs. In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task, if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us, that when the storm is long past, the ocean is flat again.

It’s hard to think of a better baseball definition of tempestuous than four games out of the Wild Card, with three teams ahead of them, and just 21 games remaining. For the majority of the 162-game season, you have to think of the long run. But when 87% of the season has already been played, you have to have a much shorter outlook.

The type of managing that made no sense in late May is what the Mets need to do the remainder of September. They need to be aggressive and do whatever it takes to win this day’s game. In my opinion, starting Lockett rather than Stroman on September 12 will give the Mets a better chance to win. And perhaps two scoreless innings out of the pen by Stroman on September 11 will be a key to victory that day, too.

8 comments on “Marcus Stroman and optimizing the rest of 2019

  • NYM6986

    Like your fix of Stroman to the pen. Not unhappy with getting him for prospects because he is a proven commodity, or at least he was. The math is against us but so is our policy of putting Nido and Frazier’s crappy bats into the lineup. We need JD or McNeil at the hot corner and ride Ramos these last 21 games. Keep the faith.

    • Brian Joura

      I actually didn’t mind Nido in the lineup last night. Thought it was worth a shot to see if he could get better results with Stroman.

      • Boomboom

        Would have been happier with Rivera

  • Chris F

    Keynesian economics lesson for a Sunday morning!!! Never know what Im gonna read.

    As much as I appreciate the “meritocracy ubber alles” angle you espouse, its simply not how this will go down. We all know that. You dont take players like Stroman who has been a front-line starter and just send him to the pen, especially not for Walter Lockett. Also the 10M$ players are all going to see plenty of time no matter how they stink; expect plenty of Cano, Frazier, Familia, and Lowrie down the stretch.

    Lets look at Diaz as an example for it being a bit more complicated than playing the old guys. After the last meltdown on friday, Callaway said explicitly: the team can only get to its destination with Diaz as an elite reliever pitching in high leverage situations. We intend to keep using him that way.

    I read that as saying heres a guy, even on a minimum salary contract, who has a job to perform as we hope, and will keep running him out there to do that very thing, succeed or fail. There is no “ride the hot streak” mentality that will govern playing time. Thats not how this game is played.

    • Brian Joura

      I don’t expect it, either, and said so explicitly in the article. This is merely what I would do if I were running things.

      • Chris F

        I know Brian. I was trying to bring a little Metsian reality to the situation! I wonder what would happen if you ran a ship as you propose. How long would you let someone “find themselves” before benching them?

        • Brian Joura

          I don’t think there’s any right answer to that question. Stroman had seven starts – it’s my belief that it isn’t reactionary to look in another direction after that many in an uphill playoff climb. Your mileage may vary.

          To me, this is the “feel” part of a managerial job. You shouldn’t manage 162 games by feel or hunches. But knowing when to make a move with a struggling veteran in a playoff chase seems to be what a manager should be attuned to. Of course, it’s wishful thinking that this is 100% the manager’s choice…

      • Peter Hyatt

        Agreed. Good article.

        These are the world’s elite baseball competitors.

        Meritocracy keeps competition going.

        I hope for that which I do not expect.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: