Van Wagenen must look for diamonds in the rough

“The Mets right now are painted into a corner. They have too many big contracts to realistically rebuild. They have too little payroll room to make a major addition without touching their core.” That’s what our fearless leader, Brian Joura eloquently stated earlier this week. My takeaway is that in order to improve this team enough to win at least five more games in 2020 to make the playoffs, Brodie Van Wagenen and his front office team are going to need to get creative this off-season.

Gus Livaditis (nice to finally know your last name) did the math for us in his post. Anticipated arbitration raises will likely make up for any savings from expiring free agent contracts, so the Mets are not going to have a lot of wiggle room between their currently expected (and roughly estimated) payroll of about $180 million and the expected luxury tax threshold of $206 million. As much as Van Wagenen has a fresh new sports car smell for Mets ownership, it’s impossible to envision a scenario where they’d open the books much more.

The Mets have a solid core. How else do explain almost making the playoffs despite having the worst bullpen in baseball, a bad defense and a knuckle headed manager? Improve those three areas and this team should be able to cross that 92-win threshold that usually guarantees a playoff spot (don’t tell Cleveland). The trick is, how do you do that without adding much to the payroll? You get creative.

Step 1 – Engage the right trade partners

2019 Playoff teams are going to be concerned with keeping their teams together and filling in at the margins. Rebuilding teams are looking to cut payroll and stockpile prospects. Neither makes a good trade partner for the Mets. We need to look at the retooling teams, the ones with talent who had disappointing seasons and the ones who suddenly accepted they might have to tear it down but haven’t begun yet. The Red Sox are like an exaggerated version of the Mets with even more talent and a bigger payroll but with bigger holes to fill. They boast one of the scariest lineups in the game but with a weak bullpen, an injury prone but expensive rotation, and several pending free agents, they’d have to go way over the luxury tax threshold to fill out the roster enough to compete with the Yankees and Astros. They need a trade partner and the Mets might be a perfect fit. Both teams have a few core players they won’t part with, a few overpriced veterans they’d love to unload, and some interesting pieces in between. The Red Sox are secretly hoping their DH, J.D. Martinez opts out of his remaining contract so they have a prayer of resigning their best player Mookie Betts, who is entering his walk year and will command a king’s ransom. However it plays out, they won’t have both for long and they’ll be desperate for pre-arbitration players who are young, can hit and play multiple positions – players like J.D. Davis and Dominic Smith. The Sox, by the way, will be in the market for a first baseman.

The Pirates were perhaps the most disappointing team in the National League, despite having a fairly talented roster. A combination of underachieving and the fallout from the Felipe Vazquez scandal will lead this team to make some wholesale changes in the offseason. Their centerfielder, Starling Marte has speed, right-handed power and a gold glove at age 31 and has two years/$24 million left on his contract. That’s not a lot of money for a good centerfielder, but it is to a rebuilding team in a secondary market. Pitcher Chris Archer is also becoming too expensive for the Pirates, but although he’d be a cheaper alternative to Zack Wheeler, his numbers are on the decline.

Other teams with talent who may make for interesting trade partners include the Cubs, Diamondbacks, Rockies, and Indians.

Step 2- Cross off the bad options

Nearly everyone reading this has taken a peak at the available free agent list and probably salivated over a few names. Charlize Theron isn’t married. That doesn’t mean you have a chance. Forget about Gerrit Cole, Anthony Rendon, who will each command and get long-term deals with AAV’s over $30 million. The next tier of players (including a few who may or may not be free agents depending on if they opt out of their current deals) will also be prohibitively expensive. It’s hard to envision the Mets doing what the Nationals did with Max Scherzer a few years back and breaking the bank to add to their already strong rotation. That means, forget about Stephen Strasburg, Madison Bumgarner, or Hyun-Jin Ryu. As much as most of us would love to see Zack Wheeler remain with the team, we could still maintain a strong rotation by slotting Seth Lugo into his place and signing a new swing man to take his spot like our old friend Collin McHugh who is a free agent. There are other free agent rotation options, including Jake Odorizzi, Dallas Keuchel, Cole Hamels (as if), Wade Miley, and Tanner Roark, and it will be interesting to see how the game of musical chairs goes. Remember, Keuchel was left without a seat last year.

One interesting name at the top of the free agent list is Aroldis Chapman. A lefty closer would sure make a nice addition to our roster and word on the street is that the Cuban Missile is going to opt out of his Yankees contract. The 32-year-old fireballer has 2 years/$34.4 million remaining so it might take at least 3 years/$54 million just to open the conversation. Will the Yankees give him that and call it a day or will he test the waters and see if he can get something like 4 years/$72 million? This would be a heck of a splash for the Mets to make, as would going after the catcher who got away last year – Yasmani Grandal – should he opt out of his deal. The 31-year-old backstop turned down the Mets reported 4-year/$60 million offer to accept Milwaukee’s 1-year/$18.25 million offer with a $16 million player option for 2020, that he’ll likely turn down. Grandal is now a year older and the Mets have Wilson Ramos under contract for next year. The Mets fan writing this would go this route and trade Ramos.

Other available catchers are mostly part-timers, backups or getting on in years.  Beyond Chapman, there are more than 60 free agent relievers to choose from, led by Will Harris, Will Smith, and Dellin Betances. Many of the names are familiar. Some are coming off good years, others off bad years. Some have been fighting injuries. There’s no telling which ones will be the 2020 Josh Hader. But there is strength in numbers. Rather than sign one guy to a $10 million deal who could fall on his face like Jeurys Familia, the smart play might be to wait out free agency and pick up three or four guys at bargain rates, including some former starters, and see where you can catch lightning in a bottle. The Mets can’t afford to go all in on one reliever and hope that he’ll be the difference maker.

Step 3- Find the diamonds in the rough 

In addition to the expected free agents, there is a long list of players with contract options who could easily join this list. In some cases the team is looking to shed payroll and declines the team option. In other instances, the player opts out in hopes of getting a bigger contract. A few interesting names to keep an eye on include pitchers Jose Quintana, Andrew Cashner, Jake Diekman, Pat Neshek, Dan Otero, Shawn Kelley, Martin Perez, Tony Watson, and Adam Warren. In addition to Grandal, there are some other catchers in this category, like Tyler Flowers and Yan Gomes. Other hitters who could opt into free agency include Kole Calhoun, Freddy Galvis, Mike Moustakas, Nick Markakis, Eric Thames, and Edwin Encarnacion.

Van Wagenen needs to do his homework ahead of the winter meetings and know going in, who has useable spare parts, who’s facing a roster crunch and who’s looking to shake things up. Just as the Mets have too many second baseman and corner outfielders, other teams have an extra catcher, or a center fielder who’s gotten too expensive, or a veteran pitcher who needs to make way for a rookie.

Step 4 – Think outside the box

The Mets have players who, due to age, injury history and contract status, couldn’t be given away for free. They also have some players they wouldn’t give up at any price – the young building blocks. But then there are the guys without a position or clear future like Smith and Davis, and the guys they’re not married to who might have value elsewhere like Ramos. There are also guys getting closer to free agency who are at peak value – guys like Noah Syndergaard and Michael Conforto. Losing Wheeler might make trading Syndergaard a bad idea, as does the fact that he’s coming off a down year. But Conforto, who also has two years of control remaining, is coming off a good year and has a lot of value as a young slugger. Rather than trading away Davis and Smith for small parts, we could let those two platoon in the outfield, or we could trade for Marte or another centerfielder and let Brandon Nimmo take right field.  Conforto is a good player and an easy guy to root for, but he’s streaky as heck and doesn’t seem to be blossoming into the second coming of Carlos Beltran as we expected. As a good, but not great player it will be too easy to let him walk in two years when his agent – Scott Boras – inevitably gets some sucker team to pony up a $200 million contract for a guy who frankly is not worth it. A Conforto trade could go a long way toward helping us rebuild the farm system, while giving us a little salary relief to put toward a real centerfielder or catcher. 

1. The Red Sox, Pirates and Cubs will be looking for trade partners this winter.
2. The free agent list includes more than 60 relief pitchers, and the Mets would be wise to roll the dice on a few from the lower to mid tier.
3. There’s a long list of interesting players who could exercise their opt-outs and join the free agent list.
4. Selling high on Michael Conforto sounds crazy, but it makes sense.

10 comments for “Van Wagenen must look for diamonds in the rough

  1. October 25, 2019 at 8:45 am

    Firstly, I tend to hate articles about trading but you’ve hit upon a pair of very good trade partners for the Mets to look at.

    Secondly, I think the Mets will give Wheeler a QO and that he will wind up accepting it.

    Thirdly, I cannot see the Mets being in on Chapman or Grandal. The Mets have Ramos and will look for a new catcher after the 2020 season.

    Fourthly, I like the idea of getting multiple relievers instead of one big guy. You just have to remember that Lugo is our closer at the moment and that doesn’t thrill me.

    Lastly, Davis and Smith for small parts is a bad plan and I hate every plan that suggests trading to valuable bats for players who aren’t likely to make impacts.

    • MattyMets
      October 25, 2019 at 9:10 am

      Dave, I would be shocked if Wheeler doesn’t get at least a 3-year deal.
      I would absolutely not trade Davis and/or Smith for the sake of trading them. However, if there is a package deal that brings a nice return, I’d be open to it. The Mets only have so many trade chips and have to use them wisely.
      Surprised you didn’t comment on Conforto.

  2. BK
    October 25, 2019 at 8:57 am

    I’m torn on Conforto. Really like him, but his value is high and I wonder if he’ll be the type of player who signs a big contract that immediately looks bad relative to performance. And after what happened with the Astros the past week, I’m not sure I want the Mets going for Chapman after already dealing with Reyes.

  3. Mike Walczak
    October 25, 2019 at 11:38 am

    Lets look further out. Rather than sign Grandal, I would rather wait and maybe bid on Realmuto when his contract is up.

    We need players, but I fear that BVW, as part of his “master plan” does not make more foolish moves.

    I have a feeling that after this offseason, we all may have to join a chapter of Van WagANON.

    • TexasGusCC
      October 27, 2019 at 2:44 am

      Mike, the Phillies were close to extending Realmuto and the belief is they will. It has been written that he isn’t looking for the biggest deal, just the best situation.

  4. Joe Gomes
    October 25, 2019 at 11:52 am

    Lets see,

    Trade Conforto in order to open up a position for a lesser player? No, Conforto is part of the core and should be locked up, not traded it.

    Absolutely you give Wheeler a QO but the point should be to bring him back. But he will be to expensive for the small market Mets.

    Lugo to the rotation? I have been saying that for years now. He is a great pitcher but can his arm take the innings required at this point?

    Trade Davis and Smith? yes to Smith, no to Davis. Mets need RH power bats and a 3B.

    Fix the pen, that’s the key and bring back Wheeler. If they do bring Wheeler back, trade Stroman for BP arms.

  5. Chris F
    October 25, 2019 at 12:11 pm

    I think BVW will need to scour the waiver wires and international markets, particularly Asia, especially with the changes in the posting scheme.

    Unless there is an uncharacteristic raise opening day payroll, you can forget any big name signings, including Wheeler, Grandal, Chapman, Cole etc etc.

    One thing that escapes me though is being so focused on depth pieces like Smith, when actual positions need better players, like C, 3B, CF. I trade Smith or Davis or Conforto or Nimmo in a hot second if you can get a solid every day starter. Smith is at least 5th in line for OF ABs (Nimmo, Conforto, Davis, McNeil, Cespedes) and never going to get more than a few at 1B. Sure he’s a great cheerleader, but if trading him or any of the corner OF glut gets a player we need, do it.

  6. October 25, 2019 at 2:12 pm

    I am predicting a quiet offseason, mainly because the payroll is so high and they came pretty close last year.

    1. Wheeler gets a QO and declines
    2. Lugo is moved to the rotation
    3. Mets sign Sergio Romo
    4. Mets sign Steve Cishek
    5. Mets sign Billy Hamilton

    In other words, they use the money they may have been on the hook for Wheeler to patch the pen and shore up late inning “D.”

    Maybe they trade Dom Smith to Boston for some of the Sox middling starting pitching prospects, with the plan being to stash them at Syracuse in case of emergency. Otherwise, that’s all folks!

  7. TJ
    October 25, 2019 at 2:25 pm

    Finding diamonds in the rough is always a good thing, and it is fun as well from the fan perspective. Hopefully with a year together organizationally, the Mets will be better positioned for this offseason from the standpoint of intelligence on their own players as well as the marketplace.

    Specifically with Smith and Davis, it is essential that the Mets have a good read on how much these guys can improve defensively. Word was that Smith was going to try to work on speed and OF skills, hopefully that is the case. These guys can have added value to the Mets, especially given the increase to a 26 man roster.

    The Mets were just under top 3rd in NL in both runs scored and runs allowed, so it will be interesting to see what improvement they value more given limited resources. I lean towards pitching, but that could just be a personal bias.

  8. NYM6986
    October 26, 2019 at 10:10 am

    Thanks for the great analysis. Believe Conforto is still improving and would not move him. Nimmo and Smith for Marte fills the CF void without sacrificing a starter. I’d rather spend FA dollars than raid the minors. Believe Wheeler will decline the QA and settle on a 3-4 year pact but not with us. The time to sign him was earlier this past season. Lots to be excited about going into 2020. Spend on the pen. If Cespedes comes back he’s worth 5 wins himself. That and less stupid managerial moves and we can contend for the division.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: