Frequently with managerial hires, clubs will look to select an individual who brings something to the table that the previous guy lacked. It’s why many were looking for Joe Girardi to get the Mets’ job. After two years with a manager who was learning on the job, fans wanted an experienced hand in the dugout. But the Mets did not travel this direction, as they went from a guy with no managerial experience to a guy with … no managerial experience.

While fans are frustrated that Girardi was there for the taking but the Mets let him go to Philadelphia, instead, they seem pretty much on board with Carlos Beltran as the team’s new skipper. Clearly, he’s well-regarded in the industry and he gave the right answers in three rounds of interviews, so hopefully he’s on the same page with the GM. Now if he can play nice with the media, we’ll be all set.

Still, the dinosaurs among us still cling to the belief that a manager should bring something to the dugout, too. With that in mind, let’s revisit an old Bill James quote and apply it to Beltran and the Mets. James said that the first job of a manager was to ask (and answer) what needs to change. Here’s my wish list for Beltran, fully recognizing that he won’t have the autonomy – or magic wand – in all (any?) of these areas.

1. Keep the twin pillars of leverage and rest in the front of his mind with his bullpen deployment.
2. Pick positions for Jeff McNeil and J.D. Davis early so they can work on that in Spring Training.
3. Handle Robinson Cano like he was any other player on the club, not one with a divine birthright.
4. Match Noah Syndergaard with Tomas Nido and don’t make a big deal out of it.
5. Install Brandon Nimmo as your leadoff guy and keep him there.
6. Keep starting pitchers as healthy as they were under Mickey Callaway.
7. Be flexible with the role and usage of Seth Lugo.
8. Don’t hire Terry Collins as your bench coach.

Whenever possible you want your best relievers on the mound when the game is on the line. If he’s on your roster, you don’t use Jacob Rhame with a one-run lead unless there’s no other option. Conversely, you don’t use your best relievers when you’re up five or more runs unless they haven’t pitched in days and you’re just looking to get them work. Let the lousy pitchers get the mop-up innings and use your good guys when the game’s on the line. It’s not that hard, yet we saw Callaway mess this up regularly.

Here in the offseason, the Mets are unsure of who’s going to play third base and who’s going to play left field. Perhaps during the offseason, the club will make a move or two that makes it obvious who’s going to play where. But if they don’t, the two likely guys are McNeil and Davis. McNeil is likely better defensively at both positions, so it’s not an easy task to give them a position. But do it early so that both guys can get as many reps as possible at their likely home. My preference is to see McNeil at third base. Last year, 3B on the Mets got 465 chances, compared to 272 for the club’s LF. Since McNeil is better, put him where he’ll see the ball more often.

Cano was installed as the club’s third-place hitter and was in that spot in the order every game he started until he returned from the IL for the second time. By that time he had a .650 OPS and was acting like an anchor in the middle of the order. And even when they dropped him, it was only to the fifth slot. By all means, if Cano is hitting like he did on the Mariners in 2016, bat him in the heart of the order. But if he’s hitting like 2019 Cano, batt him eighth. Or put him on the bench.

In 1966, in the middle of the Vietnam War, the late Senator George Aiken of Vermont recommended that the U.S. simply, “declare victory and get out.” The Mets should install Nido as Syndergaard’s personal catcher, declare victory and get out of the way. In the past two years, Syndergaard’s ERA with Nido as his catcher is 2.41 in 153 IP. With anyone else behind the plate, it’s 4.75 in 199 IP. Wilson Ramos needs days off. Give them to him when Syndergaard is pitching. This is a big problem with an easy solution. The Mets need to stop being so pig-headed about it.

Nimmo broke through in the majors late in the 2017 season, where he followed up his minor league numbers by proving he could get on base at a great clip. When he finally got the chance to play full time in 2018, he was even better, as he posted a .404 OBP, which was the fourth-best mark in the majors. But when he battled injuries last year and tried to play with them, the Mets were quite eager to move him elsewhere, unlike what they did with Cano. Even when he came back healthy in September, they had him batting low in the order. It wasn’t until September 16th when they installed him back in the leadoff spot. They went 9-3 in the 12 games he led off.

Callaway gets blamed for a lot of things. And rightly so. But one thing that happened when he was around was that the starting pitchers were remarkably healthy. In his two years on the job, the Mets had eight pitchers make at least 25 starts in a season. And Jason Vargas was on track to do that before he was dealt. Vargas and Marcus Stroman, the guy who replaced him in the rotation, combined for 29 starts. In the two previous seasons, only three pitchers made at least 25 starts in a year for the Mets. Could be nothing but a coincidence. Or it could be something that Callaway did. Beltran should look to keep whatever routines the starters had under Callaway.

Lugo started the year as a quasi-long reliever. He ended the season as the team’s closer. How does he enter 2020? No one knows at this point. It’s possible he might even start the year in the rotation. Wherever he winds up, it’s a decent bet that he’ll be needed in a different role later in the year. Last year, the Mets were adamant that he not be used as a starter. And they really couldn’t afford to lose him from the pen. It’s a strong possibility the same thing will happen this upcoming year, too. But even if the rotation isn’t an option, it’s still on the table to shift bullpen roles. Ideally, the two big reliever acquisitions last offseason revert to 2018 and Lugo can be moved to a multi-inning guy. Beltran and the Mets need to be prepared to make the switch if possible.

Collins is a nice guy. But he often seemed overmatched in the dugout trying to come up with the right move on the fly. Why would you hire someone with that skill set to be a bench coach? While a veteran guy with National League experience is a good idea for the position, let’s make it someone who doesn’t spend hours trying to figure out a lineup and seemingly that long to decide which moves to be made during the actual game. What’s R.A. Dickey doing these days? He’s a smart guy who pitched in the NL and was a teammate of Beltran’s. Make him the bench coach. Anyone but Collins.


Good luck Beltran. You were one of my favorite Mets as a player and it would be terrific if one day that phrase would be altered to include manager, too.

10 comments on “Carlos Beltran’s list of what needs to be changed

  • Mike Walczak

    Beltran has a lot of decisions to make. But it depends on what he is dealt. His strategy today will be different than what it is at the end of spring training. For example, do the Mets sign Gerrit Cole or Ivan Nova for the rotation. (We know this answer)

    How well do Diaz and Familia pitch in spring training? Who else is in the bullpen? Who is the center fielder?

    Ramos threw out 17 out of 128 baserunners for a 13% rate. Nido threw out 3 out of 40 for a 8% rate. Lets face it, both numbers are terrible. Nido hit .191 last year and .167 the year before that. OK, so Syndergaard has a lower ERA when Nido catches. We are stuck with Ramos, but we can get a better backup who can be used as a backup should be used.

    So, I am saying is lets get Beltran some good tools, so that he can make good decisions and “changes” that are need to win.

    Thanks for writing the article.

    • Brian Joura

      A catcher who can shave 2+ runs off a pitcher’s ERA is worth having. Maybe the sample sizes aren’t big enough but if they’re not, they’re mighty close.

      There are enough problems to fix. There’s no point adding backup catcher to the list when the current guy has displayed the ability to get great results with an alleged ace pitcher.

      • Mike W

        Ok – fair enough.

  • Metsense

    If the Mets don’t make any changes before spring training then I’m all behind your 8 points. Your number one point, leverage and rest in the bullpen is paramount. Your reasoning about McNeil as the third baseman makes the most logical sense. Cano should have his time reduced and his position in the batting order lowered until or if when he earns it. The Syndergaard and Nido situation is a serviceable solution but I would rather trade Ramos , sign Wheeler and trade Syndergaard but that solution is beyond the scope of this article. Beltran will need a strong bench coach who has experience managing or bench coaching in the National League who is not named Terry Collins.

    • Brian Joura

      On one hand, you’ll get more chances at 3B. But on the other hand, if you screw up in the infield, it’s likely only a single. If you screw up in the OF, it’s likely extra bases, with the possibility of an inside the park HR. Ultimately, I think the rest of the infield defense is bad, that it would be nice to have one plus defender there. Conforto has been an average fielder in RF, which is more than you can say for the infielders.

  • José

    Yes! Absolutely get RAD¹ as bench coach. Given how totally beloved he is among the fan base, it would be a PR coup. And bringing back “The Vulture” as pitching coach is mandatory, regardless of his age

    ¹ – hope I didn’t violate the “all caps” rule!

  • Ari

    Here is what I noticed about Cano. His first 10 (approximately) games of the season he was great. Then he went cold. He got hurt and when he came back his first 10 or so games back he was great, then he got ice cold for a long stretch. Then he went on the DL for a long stretch. His first 10 or so games back, he was great until he cooled off again.

    It is clear that he just doesn’t have the stamina to play everyday. As a player limited to 3 or 4 games a week he might thrive. More than that and he will become an anchor that will pull the team down.

    Editor’s Note – Please do not capitalize words in your post, as that is a violation of our Comment Policy.

    • Brian Joura

      This sounds good but it doesn’t match up with reality.

      Cano played pretty much every day until he went on the IL. After two hits and a homer on Opening Day, he was terrible for the next 16 games, posting a .515 OPS in that span. His first 10 games after coming back from the IL, he had a .548 OPS.

      The 10-day thing worked our when he returned from the IL in September but you’ve got to have more than one right in three for the theory to be taken seriously.

    • Name

      The stats don’t support your recollection.

      He hit a HR in his first game.The next 20 games he was ice cold with a 646 OPS.
      When he got hurt in May and came back in June – he was ice cold.
      When he got hurt in August and came back in september, he did get hot but against AAAA competition.

      Besides a few week stretch playing against lesser competition in september, he had no real meaningful stretch of productivity.

  • MattyMets

    What new tools will Beltran be given to work with? Easy to question Callaway’s bullpen management, but maybe it wouldn’t have been under such scrutiny if Familia and Diaz were even half as good as expected.

    How much leeway will Beltran have with setting lineups, positions, etc or will this all come down from the FO? My guess is not much. There’s a reason the Mets passed up a chance to hire Girardi and wouldn’t even talk to Showalter. They want a coach, not a manager.

    Most importantly, how will the players respond to Beltran? Will they be motivated to perform under a former star player they admire or will they lose confidence in him if he makes questionable in-game decisions?

Leave a Reply to Mike W Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: