Flores LagaresIf you go way way back in Mets history you know that the earliest off seasons featured the team’s front office just trying to add some major league caliber players to the roster. But if you fast forward to the modern era of bullpen usage you know that one off season task the Mets continually have is fixing the bullpen. And once again it is something that has to be addressed in the next few months.

But a pair of extremely important tasks involve a middle infielder and a middle outfielder. If we assume that neither Wilmer Flores nor Juan Lagares gets traded then the GM and manager will have to carve out roles for their 2016 season. Actually were the Mets to gamble and trade for the enigmatic Yasiel Puig it is certainly possible that Lagares could be partial payment in that swap.

In Wilmer’s case the team is saying one thing but seemingly acting differently. What we hear is that they are ready to once again go with Flores as the team’s #1 shortstop. But the rumor mill has them checking in on any and everyone who might be able to cover the position for them.

My opinion, often stated in my weekly articles, is that Flores lacks the range and fluidity required to play an acceptable shortstop at the major league level. This is not to say that Wilmer Flores is not a talent deserving of a full, or at least a close to fulltime job. With the power to hit 15 or more homeruns and play multiple infield positions there should be a job for him. It’s just that that job probably should not be day-in-day-out shortstop.

In a best case scenario the Mets can land a better defensive shortstop (not that hard to do) and have him be someone who can contribute offensively (now there’s the rub). If that is done then the Mets could either slide Flores over to second base or should he lose a spring training competition with Dilson Herrera then he could become the backup at every infield position. Knowing the precariousness of David Wright’s spinal stenosis it could mean extensive duty at third base. One can easily imagine Flores logging 400 at bats while providing all the infielders periodic days off.

In Lagares’ case the questions are twofold. One is how healthy and serviceable is his right elbow. If the winter months bring a full healing then Juan can go back to being a plus plus defender whose defensive contribution will make up for the fact that he is really not much of a hitter.

On the other hand if his elbow continues barking and his arm strength continues to be more like Curtis Granderson’s than Yoenis Cespedes’ it is most likely that he will have to become the short half of a centerfield platoon. Then the question is with whom he would share the position. The in-house choices are underwhelming and include Kirk Nieuwenheis and Darrel Ceciliani. Perhaps there might be a Brandon Nimmo sighting here if he starts off promisingly at double-A or triple-A.

More likely the Mets will be going the trade or free agent route to bring in an outfielder capable of being the long half of the platoon. Popular names out there include Geraldo Parra, Dexter Fowler, and perhaps Boston’s Jackie Bradley.

It will be most interesting to see how GM Alderson handles the Flores and Lagares situations.

5 comments on “Mets need to find roles for Wilmer Flores and Juan Lagares

  • Metsense

    Larry, a very thoughtful and interesting article. Buttonholing Flores into a role is much easier than the Lagares situation. Flores as a utility man has a better chance of success. It will be difficult to sign a free agent as a platoon partner for Lagares. That leaves the Mets to the trade route. To get a good young cost controlled shortstop will probably cost a pitcher. It is for this reason a trade that included Harvey for Boegarts and Bradley may be appealing for both teams.

  • Steve S.

    Lagares is one season away from being healthy and having a 5.7 WAR (in only 116 games). He also hit well in the minors and looked better at the plate later in the season. And he’ll only be 27 next year. I think he could be very good in 2016.

    • Larry Smith

      Have to disagree with you Steve S.
      Lagares was in no way a good minor league hitter. In over 2400 minor league ABs Lagares put up an OPS of 725. That might be barely tolerable for a shortstop or catching prospect but is nowhere near what you want from an outfielder. His projections have him pegged for a sub 700 OPS. He is not much of a hitter at all. Only a platinum glove makes him acceptable as a major leaguer.
      Thank you for the comment though.

      • Steve S.

        Larry: I’m looking at some minor league stats for Juan, beginning in 2011 (when he was 22), discounting what he did in the low minors when he was 17-21. Not so bad: .338/.380/.494/.873; .370/.391/.512/ .903; .283/.334/.389/.723; .346/.378/.551/.929.

        • Larry Smith

          I think you’re cherry picking your examples. That 2013 929 OPS was put up in only 78 ABs at about the easiest park to hit in in the easiest league to hit in, the Pacific Coast League. One could probably find a 78 AB sample for Anthony Recker, Eric Campbell, or Danny Muno that looks as impressive at Las Vegas.
          Two things I would hang my hat on is Lagares’ 499 ABs at dblA as a 23 year old where he put up a 723 OPS which just is not good enough for an outfielder.
          Also remember he was expected to be beaten out for a job by Matt denDekker and we all know that that’s a guy who has never hit at the major league level.
          If Lagares is actually a major league average hitter then surely other GMs would be coming to the Mets for him and clearly nobody has.
          Alderson wanted to include him in the deal for Carlos Gomez and the Milwaukee GM said he wouldn’t want him.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 100 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here